For education only, not tax, legal or investment advice.
Every harvest that ends in a purchase runs into the same two words. Section 1091 disallows a loss when you acquire “substantially identical stock or securities” within 30 days before or after the sale, then leaves the phrase undefined. For a single stock that rarely matters. For index funds, ETFs and options it’s the whole question. This page goes further than the short version in our wash sale guide: what the IRS has said, what it hasn’t, and how careful and aggressive readings fill the gap. It doesn’t pick a side.
The IRS has never published a list
IRS Publication 550 adds one instruction to the statute: “In determining whether stock or securities are substantially identical, you must consider all the facts and circumstances in your particular case.” The closest thing to a definition sits in the short-sale regulations. Treas. Reg. §1.1233-1(d)(1) gives the term the same meaning it has in §1091 and repeats the same few examples. Neither passage has a list, a percentage, or a word about mutual funds or ETFs.
What is fixed:
- The same security. Buying back what you sold, in any account you or your spouse own, is the core case.
- A contract or option to buy it. §1091 names these outright. It also counts options as “stock or securities” in their own right, so a loss on an option can be washed too.
- Another company’s stock. Ordinarily not substantially identical. Pub 550’s example of an exception is a reorganization, where the predecessor’s and successor’s stock may be.
- A company’s bonds or preferred stock against its common. Ordinarily not, though convertibles that trade like the common can be.
Everything else, including every swap of one fund for another, is a reading of that facts-and-circumstances sentence.
Funds: same fund, same index, different index
Pub 550’s wash sale section never mentions funds. A discontinued IRS publication on mutual fund distributions, Publication 564, did, in one line: “Ordinarily, shares issued by one mutual fund are not considered to be substantially identical to shares issued by another mutual fund.” It never said when the ordinary case stops applying. Funds sort into three groups, and the answers get less certain as you go.
Same fund, another share class
Some funds sell one portfolio under several tickers. VOO is the ETF share class of the Vanguard 500 Index Fund, which also sells Admiral shares as a mutual fund: same holdings, same managers, same fund. Selling one class at a loss and buying the other inside the window changes the wrapper and little else, and each reading below treats that as substantially identical. Your broker isn’t required to flag it, because each class has its own CUSIP.
Same index, another sponsor
SPY, IVV and VOO all track the S&P 500. SPY is a unit investment trust, IVV is an iShares ETF, and VOO is that Vanguard share class. Are any two of them substantially identical? No IRS ruling says. The two sides argue it like this:
- The aggressive reading: different issuers. Each fund is a separate issuer, and Pub 550’s starting point is that one corporation’s securities ordinarily aren’t substantially identical to another’s. The old Pub 564 line said the same of funds. The three also differ in legal structure, fees, securities lending and how they handle dividends.
- The careful reading: same economics. The rule exists to deny a loss when your position hasn’t really changed. Two funds holding the same 500 stocks at the same weights move almost in lockstep, so the swap changes the ticker and little else. The IRS has looked past form before: in Rev. Rul. 85-87 it treated a put as a contract to buy because of what the put would almost certainly do.
Different index, similar market
An S&P 500 fund and a total-market fund such as VTI follow different indexes; the total-market index adds thousands of mid-size and small companies. SCHD and VYM, two popular dividend ETFs, follow different dividend indexes with different screens. Automated harvesting services build on this line. Betterment’s published methodology, for one, notes that the IRS hasn’t said same-index funds are substantially identical, and calls a closely correlated fund on a different index the more conservative choice.
The critique runs the other way. S&P says its 500 companies cover about 80% of the US market’s available value, so a total-market fund keeps most of its weight in the same stocks an S&P 500 fund owns. Planning writer Michael Kitces has argued that once two funds’ daily returns correlate above about 0.95, and especially at 0.99, it’s hard to call them anything but substantially identical, whatever their index names.
The working tests people use
None of these comes from the IRS, and they don’t agree with each other:
- Same fund only. Another share class of the same fund counts; every other fund doesn’t. The aggressive reading, taken at its word.
- Same index. A replacement on the same index counts; a different index doesn’t. The robo-adviser line.
- Correlation. Two funds whose returns move together at about 0.95 or more are treated as identical, whatever their indexes.
- Holdings overlap. Some advisers borrow a 70% line from Treas. Reg. §1.246-5, a rule about hedged stock positions for the dividends-received deduction, as Morningstar’s Sheryl Rowling has suggested. It was never written for wash sales. Run its arithmetic on an S&P 500 fund and a total-market fund and the overlap comes out near that 80%, past the line.
The middle case is where they split: against an S&P 500 fund, a total-market fund passes the same-fund and same-index tests and can fail the correlation and overlap tests.
One fund swap, read both ways
You own an S&P 500 fund, call it Fund A, that cost $28,800. It falls, and you sell the whole position for $26,400, a $2,400 loss. The same afternoon the $26,400 goes into Fund B, another sponsor’s S&P 500 fund.
- If Fund B is substantially identical to Fund A: the $2,400 is disallowed for now and added to Fund B’s basis, $26,400 + $2,400 = $28,800. Fund A’s holding period carries over under §1223(3). The loss comes back when Fund B is sold without another wash.
- If it isn’t: the $2,400 is a capital loss this year. Fund B’s basis is its $26,400 cost, and its holding period starts the day after the purchase.
One wrinkle the example sidesteps: the rule matches shares one for one, and no guidance says how to do that between two funds with different share prices. The figures assume a full, dollar-for-dollar replacement.
Either way, your 1099-B shows the $2,400 loss and an empty box 1g. A broker only has to apply the wash sale rule when the replacement has the same CUSIP and sits in the same account (Treas. Reg. §1.6045-1(d)(6)(iii)), and Fund B has its own. The judgment is yours, and so is the reporting: Pub 550 says a wash sale loss can’t be deducted even if the 1099-B doesn’t show it. If you conclude it was a wash, Form 8949 takes code W in column (f) and the $2,400 in column (g).
One variation raises the stakes. If Fund B is bought in your IRA and the two funds are substantially identical, the $2,400 doesn’t wait in a basis. Under Rev. Rul. 2008-5 it’s gone.
Options: when a contract counts as buying the stock
Options get more guidance than funds, starting with the statute itself. A call is an option to buy. Buy one inside the window of a loss sale on the same stock, and the loss is washed for the shares the call covers. Sell 300 shares at a $1,500 loss, $5 a share, and buy one standard 100-share call in the window: $500 is disallowed and added to the call’s cost, and the other $1,000 stands.
Deep-in-the-money puts
Selling a put commits you to buy only if the holder exercises. Rev. Rul. 85-87 (1985-1 C.B. 268) dealt with a put that was all but certain to be exercised. A taxpayer sold 100 shares at a loss and, the next day, sold a put obliging the seller to buy 100 shares, within less than two months, at a strike well above the market price. Weighing the gap between price and strike, the put’s term, the premium, the stock’s historical volatility and other objective factors, the IRS found no substantial likelihood the put would go unexercised. In substance it was a contract to buy, and the loss was disallowed.
The ruling sets no number. It doesn’t say how deep “deep” is, and it doesn’t address puts sold at or out of the money. Its factors are the only guide.
The other two basic trades don’t acquire anything. Writing a call is an obligation to sell, and buying a put is an option to sell, so neither washes a loss on the stock under §1091. Positions that offset each other can still fall under the separate straddle rules of §1092, which defer losses on their own terms.
Losses on the options themselves
Because §1091 treats options as securities, a loss on an option can be washed too. Sell a call at a loss and buy the same contract back within 30 days, same stock, strike and expiration, and it’s an ordinary wash. Brokers generally report that one, since the contract is identical.
Rolls are the open question: closing a contract at a loss and opening one on the same stock with a different strike or expiration. No ruling covers it. The nearest IRS analysis is an internal General Counsel Memorandum, GCM 38285. As KPMG summarizes it, the memo treated buying back a call with the same expiration and a different strike as a wash, while allowing that two calls might be “somewhat dissimilar” when one strike sits far above the stock’s price. A GCM isn’t binding. The aggressive reading borrows the bond test below and counts strike and expiration as material terms. The careful reading treats a same-day roll at a loss as a wash, since the bet on the stock barely changed. A broker only has to report washes between identical contracts, so a roll usually leaves box 1g empty either way.
Written options leave one more gap. §1091(e) extends the rule to losses on closing short sales, and no ruling says how that applies to a written call that’s bought back at a loss and written again.
Bonds and preferred stock
Pub 550 and the short-sale regulations both say a company’s bonds or preferred stock ordinarily aren’t substantially identical to its common. Convertibles are the exception, because “the relative values, price changes, and other circumstances” can make them so. Pub 550 lists when preferred stock counts as identical to the common. The preferred:
- is convertible into the common,
- has the same voting rights,
- is subject to the same dividend restrictions,
- trades at prices that don’t vary significantly from the conversion ratio, and
- is unrestricted as to convertibility.
Warrants run one way. Selling common stock at a loss and buying warrants for the same company’s common at the same time is a wash, Pub 550 says; selling warrants at a loss and buying the common is a wash only if the two are substantially identical.
For one bond against another, Rev. Rul. 58-211 (1958-1 C.B. 529) set the test still cited: bonds aren’t substantially identical if they differ substantially in any material feature, or in several taken together. Interest rate, maturity and issuer are the features usually weighed. Bond funds get no special rule; the fund tests above apply.
What about crypto?
Coins and tokens held directly aren’t “stock or securities,” and the IRS treats virtual currency as property (Notice 2014-21), so §1091 doesn’t reach them under the law in force on the review date below. Congress has weighed extending the rule to digital assets, and at least one proposal would reach back to sales made before it became law.
The questions that decide it
This isn’t a recommendation to buy or sell anything. It’s the list of facts that decide how a replacement is likely to be read, and who has to report it.
- Is it the same security under another name? Another share class of the same fund, or a successor’s stock after a reorganization.
- Does it track the same index? That’s the gray zone, with no ruling either way.
- How close is it? Holdings overlap, and how tightly the two move together.
- Did an option stand in for the stock? A call bought or a deep-in-the-money put sold inside the window, or a losing contract rolled on the same stock.
- Where was it bought? Every account you or your spouse own counts, and a buy in your IRA turns a wash into a permanent loss.
- Will anyone else catch it? Only same-CUSIP, same-account washes reach box 1g. The rest is yours to report.
The wash sale calculator gives the window dates for any ticker, and with a plan it keeps option legs next to your stock trades on the same ticker: call or put, strike, expiration, and whether you opened, closed, rolled or let it expire. An option you bought is checked against a stock loss’s window like any other buy. It matches by ticker, so it can’t tell you whether two different funds are substantially identical. Neither can your broker.
Sources
- IRS Publication 550, “Wash Sales”: substantially identical, options and futures contracts, warrants, and box 1g: irs.gov/publications/p550
- IRC §1091, including the options sentence in (a) and short sales in (e): law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/26/1091
- Treas. Reg. §1.1233-1(d)(1), substantially identical property: law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/26/1.1233-1
- Treas. Reg. §1.6045-1(d)(6)(iii), broker wash sale reporting (same CUSIP, same account): law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/26/1.6045-1
- IRS Publication 564, Mutual Fund Distributions (discontinued), “Substantially identical”: irs.gov prior-year archive
- Rev. Rul. 85-87, 1985-1 C.B. 268 (in-the-money put treated as a contract to buy)
- Rev. Rul. 58-211, 1958-1 C.B. 529 (bonds and material features)
- Rev. Rul. 2008-5 (IRA and Roth IRA repurchases): irs.gov/pub/irs-drop/rr-08-05.pdf
- IRS Notice 2014-21 (virtual currency treated as property): irs.gov/pub/irs-drop/n-14-21.pdf
- Treas. Reg. §1.246-5(c)(1)(iii), the 70% substantial-overlap test: law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/26/1.246-5
- KPMG, “Wash sale transactions: current law and proposals” (summary of GCM 38285): kpmg.com
- Betterment, tax-loss harvesting methodology (index-based replacements): betterment.com
- Michael Kitces, “The Wash Sale Problem When Tax Loss Harvesting ‘Almost’ Substantially Identical Mutual Funds And ETFs”: kitces.com
- Sheryl Rowling, “Wash Sale Challenge: What Is Substantially Identical?”, Morningstar: morningstar.com
- S&P Dow Jones Indices, S&P 500 index description (about 80% of available market capitalization): spglobal.com/spdji
For education only. Not tax, legal, or investment advice. Verify with IRS Publication 550 or a tax professional before acting.
Comments are closed