At these rates, KO’s payouts stay under the interest on savings at 3.59% for all 10 years, and with payouts reinvested it is worth more from year 1. After 10 years: $28,608 in KO, $14,229 in savings.
KO’s payouts do not pass the interest for good within 10 years.
KO’s Worst Year
In its worst year (1974, payouts reinvested) KO fell 57.2%: $10,000 would have dropped to $4,280. A savings balance does not fall.
Dividend Funds Against the Same Savings Account
| Ticker ⇵ | Safety Rating ⇵ | Yield today ⇵ | Payout growth ⇵ | Price growth ⇵ | Worth more from ⇵ | Payouts pass interest ⇵ | After 10 years ⇵ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| KOThe Coca-Cola Company | Dividend Safety Rating: paid plans only | 2.13% | 4.5% | 9.2% | Year 1 | Not in 10 yrs | $28,608 |
| SCHDSchwab U.S. Dividend Equity ETF | Dividend Safety Rating: paid plans only | 2.96% | 9.1% | 9.8% | Year 1 | Year 3 | $33,885 |
| VYMVanguard High Dividend Yield ETF | Dividend Safety Rating: paid plans only | 2.17% | 3.8% | 8.4% | Year 1 | Not in 10 yrs | $26,680 |
| DGROiShares Core Dividend Growth ETF | Dividend Safety Rating: paid plans only | 1.88% | 7.1% | 11.2% | Year 1 | Not in 10 yrs | $33,780 |
| VIGVanguard Dividend Appreciation ETF | Dividend Safety Rating: paid plans only | 1.48% | 9.1% | 11.5% | Year 1 | Not in 10 yrs | $33,905 |
| QQQIsince Jan 2024 | Dividend Safety Rating: paid plans only | 15.19% | 0.2% | 0.2% | Year 1 | Year 1 | $46,156 |
| SPYIsince Aug 2022 | Dividend Safety Rating: paid plans only | 11.78% | 1.3% | 1.3% | Year 1 | Year 1 | $36,745 |
Savings after 10 years at the same inputs: $14,229. Click a column to sort. QQQI and SPYI have short records here (from Jan 2024 and Aug 2022), so their rates rest on a few years only.
How the Calculator Works
- Savings compounds monthly. Each month the balance earns one twelfth of the year, so a full year adds exactly the rate you type.
- Payouts buy more shares on the day they are paid when Reinvest is on. KO pays 4 times a year. Reinvest off collects payouts and interest as cash instead.
- Yield today is the run rate: the last payout times the payouts a year, divided by the latest price.
- Worth more from is the year the stock or fund passes the cash balance and stays ahead through the last year shown. Payouts pass interest works the same way for the money paid each year.
- Taxes and inflation are not counted. Savings interest is taxed as ordinary income. Type each rate after your own tax to compare.
Questions About Dividends vs a High-Yield Savings Account
When does SCHD beat a high-yield savings account?
At 3.59% savings and SCHD’s own rates (2.96% yield, payout growth 9.1% a year, price growth 9.8% a year), $10,000 with payouts reinvested is worth more than the savings from year 1. Its payouts pass the interest in year 3. After 10 years: $33,885 against $14,229. SCHD’s price can fall: in its worst year here, 2018, it lost 5.6% with payouts reinvested.
Is SGOV the same as a savings account?
SGOV holds short-term Treasury bills and pays every month. Its run-rate yield is 3.94% today, 4.15% a year ago and 4.96% two years ago. Its price barely moves: its worst calendar year here was +0.05%. Most savings accounts pay a little less, so this page starts savings 0.35 points lower, at 3.59%.
What about QQQI or SPYI?
QQQI pays 15.19% today (record from Jan 2024, price up 0.2% a year since then). SPYI pays 11.78% today (record from Aug 2022, price up 1.3% a year since then). Both are young funds, so their rates rest on a short record. Load either one above to see the same crossover years.
What if savings rates fall?
Then the interest drops and the crossover comes sooner. Cash pays whatever rates pay: SGOV paid 3.94% today and 4.15% a year ago. Type a lower cash rate above to see it.
How far can SCHD fall?
SCHD’s deepest price fall here was 33.4%, from Jan 23, 2020 to Mar 23, 2020. It was back at the old high on Nov 9, 2020. Its record here starts in Oct 2011, so it leaves out the 2008 crash.
How this page is built: daily closing prices and payouts for SGOV, KO, SCHD, VYM, DGRO, VIG, QQQI, SPYI, through Nov 16, 2026. Yield is the run rate: the last payout times that payout’s payouts a year, divided by the latest close. Payout growth is the yearly rate between the payout per share paid (by ex-date) in the first and last full years of the last 5, or over the full years a younger fund has; with fewer than 2 full years, its last year of payouts against the year before. Price growth is the yearly rate of the closing price over the last 10 years, or the whole record when shorter. Worst year and deepest fall come from each record here; worst years reinvest each payout at the close on its ex-date. The projection is arithmetic on the rates shown, which you can change; a replayed year moves the price and the payouts by the same change. This is data, not investment advice.